Seller Disclosure Disputes

Seller Disclosure Disputes

Every month over 2,000 homes are sold in the Kansas City Metro area. The vast majority of these sales go off without a hitch, but for a small percentage the closing of the sale is just the beginning. Days, months, or sometimes years after the sale, the buyer discovers issues with the home that were not disclosed on the Seller Disclosure form. The issues might be small — like a small leak in the basement — or large — like a major foundation issue. The buyer is mad and feels like someone should be responsible for not telling him or her about this issue and maybe contacts a lawyer.

Many attorneys who practice real estate law have very limited experience with seller disclosure disputes and general litigation attorneys likely have no experience in the are.  Seller Disclosure disputes are complicated and often involve many parties, such as the buyer, seller, real estate agent and inspector.  The rules for liability are different than most consumer transactions, and therefore, having an attorney experienced in handling these types of matters can help buyers from making costly mistakes in bringing litigation where there is a limited chance of recovery.  Moreover, for the defendants in these type actions, hiring an attorney who is experienced in handling seller disclosure disputes can help ensure that all available defenses are being explored and you have the greatest chance of success at trial.

When are sellers liable for undisclosed defects?

3105615966_ed5131d750_bThis is a difficult question to answer without the specific facts in a situation.  The general rule in both Kansas and Missouri is “buyer beware” or that the burden is on the buyer to conduct inspections or identify problems prior to closing.  With that being said, courts in both states recognize that the unique nature of a home renders some defects undiscoverable during the buying process (for example, mold inside walls can not be discovered without cutting into the walls).  For a seller to be liable, the seller must have known about the issue and not disclosed it.  Moreover, the issue must not have been discoverable during a reasonable inspection.  If a seller disclosed part of an issue, but not the entire extent of it, he or she may not be liable if the information that was disclosed was enough to “put the buyer on notice” of the potential issue.  For these reasons, it is important that buyers consult with an attorney who has experience dealing with these type issues prior to proceeding to litigation.  Seller disclosure cases can be won, but it is important to fully understand the strength of the case before spending money on litigation.

What about the real estate agent or inspector?

Establishing liability for real estate agents and inspectors is even more difficult than against sellers because it is the seller that should have the most knowledge regarding the condition of the house.  Real estate agents are generally not liable for undisclosed issues unless they had specific knowledge of an issue and make affirmative statements to the contrary.  Inspectors are not liable for issues that are concealed, such as within walls, and otherwise not discoverable through a reasonable inspection.  Even when an inspector misses an item that was easily discoverable, it is common for inspectors to include terms in their contracts to limit their liability for errors.  These contractual terms do not 100% shield an inspector from liability, but it does make a case against an inspector more difficult.  Finally, it should be noted that inspectors hired by the bank and/or the bank issuing you a mortgage are not liable for failing to discover issues with the property.  The duty of a bank inspector or appraiser is to the bank and not the buyer.  Therefore, only the bank would have a potential recourse against that inspector or appraiser.

How can I get more information?

Our website contains additional information related to real estate litigation issues and answers to frequently asked questions that can be found by searching using the search box located in the top left corner of this website or by browsing through our blog posts by clicking here.   If you would like to schedule a consultation to discuss your situation and our services, please either give us a call at 913-210-1847 or click on this link to see available times for a consultation.